The 2004 documentary The Conscientious Objector is the most complete publicly available visual record of Doss speaking about his own experience. Watching a man in his eighties describe what he did in his twenties, in his own voice, with his own rhythm and his own framing, is a different experience from reading accounts of what he said. The documentary does not replace the documentary record, but it provides something the documentary record cannot: the actual man, talking.

## The Specific Costs of Not Killing

The standard framing of Desmond Doss’s story emphasizes what he gained: the Medal of Honor, the recognition, the institutional vindication of his position. The less examined side is what his position cost him.

The harassment during training was not trivial. Shoes thrown at a man while he prays, threats to shoot him in combat, sustained institutional pressure intended to force a choice between his faith and his right to serve — these are real costs paid over real months of his life. The men doing these things were not doing them playfully; they were doing them with intent. Doss absorbed this without fighting back and without abandoning his position, but absorbing it was not free.

The furloughs denied by Captain Cunningham meant he did not see his brother Harold before Harold’s ship deployed. Harold survived the kamikaze attack on the USS Lindsey. If he had not, the furlough denial would have been the reason Desmond never saw his brother again before Harold died. This is not a hypothetical designed to demonize Cunningham; it is the actual structure of what the denial meant in a context where naval vessels were being sunk by suicide aircraft.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.