His son, Peter J. Elliott, had by this point inherited both the case and his father’s commitment to it. Peter Elliott became the U.S. Marshal for the Northern District of Ohio in 2003. The Conrad case was by then a legacy assignment—a case that had outlasted careers and, now, a life. “It always stayed on my dad’s mind,” Pete Elliott said. “We kept this case going because it was important to my father.”
What the elder Elliott had not wasted was his time accumulating documents. Among the materials he had gathered from Conrad’s college days—from New England College, from Cuyahoga Community College, from the period before the theft—was a document bearing Conrad’s signature. A signature from the 1960s, preserved in investigative files, connected to a young man who had been twenty years old when he vanished and had not been seen since.
—
## What the Obituary Said
In November 2021, Peter Elliott came across an obituary for a man named Thomas Randele of Lynnfield, Massachusetts.
The obituary had been posted after Randele’s death in May 2021. It named his birth date: July 10, 1947. It listed his parents’ first names. It mentioned the same college. It mentioned the same mother’s maiden name.
Theodore John Conrad’s actual birth date was July 10, 1949. Someone who needed to create an identity that was close enough to remember but different enough to pass scrutiny might reasonably shift the birth year by two, keeping the month and day—and most importantly, keeping the parents’ names, the college, the mother’s maiden name, because those were the details a memory could hold and a lie would lose.