Spread-spectrum technology had multiple independent origins. The mathematician Claude Shannon had theorized about spreading signal energy across frequency bands in his foundational information theory work. Caltech engineer Robert Price and MIT’s Paul Green were developing spread-spectrum systems in the 1950s. Qualcomm’s engineers built CDMA — Code Division Multiple Access — for commercial wireless telephony in the 1980s and 1990s. Ericsson developed frequency-hopping systems that became part of the Bluetooth standard. IEEE engineers designed the COFDM and OFDSS systems that underlie Wi-Fi.

None of these systems was built from the Lamarr-Antheil patent. The patent expired before any of them existed. But the concept of defeating interference by distributing signals across frequencies — the concept that Lamarr articulated from her knowledge of wartime radio problems and that Antheil solved using his knowledge of player-piano synchronization — was the same fundamental insight.

The accurate framing is: Lamarr and Antheil independently arrived at an important idea, described it in a patent that was never implemented, and the same underlying idea was later independently arrived at by other engineers who built it into working systems that changed the world. The conceptual lineage is real. The engineering lineage is not direct.

## What Recognition Looked Like, When It Finally Arrived

In 1997, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, an organization dedicated to digital civil liberties, awarded its Pioneer Award jointly to Hedy Lamarr and George Antheil — posthumously in Antheil’s case, since he had died in 1959. The award recognized their contribution to the concept of spread-spectrum communication. Lamarr, who was eighty-two years old and living in Florida, did not attend the ceremony. Her son accepted on her behalf. Her reported reaction, when told she was receiving the award, was: “It’s about time.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.