The significance of this is not merely symbolic. The Oscars in 1973 were watched by approximately 85 million Americans — a large fraction of the adult population. The statement made from that stage reached people who had not been reached by AIM’s activities, by federal hearings on treaty violations, by journalism about the Wounded Knee standoff. It reached them in an entertainment context, in a moment when they were prepared to receive information as entertainment, and it named something — the treatment of American Indians by the film industry — that the entertainment context had systematically suppressed.

Whether that naming changed anything is hard to measure. The history of representation in the decades that followed suggests that the change was slow and incomplete. But the naming itself was a form of accountability: a moment in which a practice that the industry had conducted in relative public silence was acknowledged to exist, in the most public possible forum, before the largest possible audience.

Brando did not attend the ceremony. He sent someone who would be willing to face the room in his name. That person faced the room, said what she went there to say, and spent fifty years living with the consequences.

The Academy spent fifty years deciding what its own conduct had been worth.

## Resolution Without Resolution: The Ongoing Question of Representation

The Academy’s 2022 apology to Sacheen Littlefeather is a milestone in the institutional history of Hollywood’s relationship with Indigenous representation — and it is not a resolution.

The apology acknowledged a specific wrong. It arrived in a specific woman’s final months. It did not change the underlying conditions that made the 1973 protest necessary. Those conditions have changed, in various degrees, over fifty years — through the efforts of Indigenous filmmakers, through sustained advocacy by Native artists and scholars, through structural changes at institutions including the Academy itself, and through the slow and imperfect expansion of who gets to tell stories in mainstream American film and television.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.