Alberta Gay, who had been his wife, responded to these statements with a degree of skepticism. She told biographers that her husband had shown no remorse initially—that he “wasn’t apologetic or repentant” in the immediate aftermath. Whether the sentencing statements reflected genuine remorse or a legal performance calibrated to a courtroom is something only Gay Sr. could have answered.
He died of pneumonia on October 10, 1998, at age 84.
—
PART TWENTY-FIVE: THE HOUSE ON GRAMERCY—AND WHAT IT MEANS
There is something about the geography of Marvin Gaye’s death that refuses to settle.
He had escaped his father’s house as a teenager by enlisting in the Air Force. He had spent decades building a life—a very large life, in very many places—that put physical distance between himself and the man who had beaten him as a child.
And then, at the end, he came back.
He moved back into the house his own money had bought for his parents. He put himself under the same roof as the man who had made his childhood a site of regular terror.
Some analysts have described this as evidence of his death wish—the final phase of a long, slow move toward an ending. Others have described it more practically: he was broke, he was addicted, he had no other options, and his parents’ house was the only shelter available.
Both things can be true simultaneously. The financial explanation doesn’t foreclose the psychological one. A man can be genuinely broke and genuinely exhausted and still, somewhere beneath the surface, be moving toward something that frightens and pulls at him.