It adds one more layer to a portrait of a man who was deeply contradictory—who demanded rigid conformity from his children while living in significant contradiction with the values he claimed to uphold.
—
THE WOMEN IN MARVIN’S ORBIT: A FULLER PICTURE
The biographical record of Marvin Gaye’s relationships with women is complicated, and it needs to be engaged with honestly.
He was genuinely capable of love. The people who knew him well—Anna Gordy Gaye, Janis Hunter, his long-time collaborators—consistently described a man who could be deeply warm, tender, and attentive when he was present. His music is testimony to this: “What’s Going On” is an act of love toward a world in pain; “Mercy Mercy Me” is an act of love toward a planet being destroyed; “Sexual Healing” is, whatever else it is, a record of a man who understood human vulnerability and need with unusual precision.
But he was also a man who caused real harm to the women in his life.
Anna Gordy Gaye was seventeen years older than Marvin, and the marriage—on the evidence of those who knew them—contained real affection alongside real volatility. Multiple accounts suggest that Anna was physically and verbally aggressive toward Marvin at times. Anna’s response to *Here, My Dear*—she reportedly considered suing him for invasion of privacy—indicates how personally she experienced the album’s disclosures.
And yet: by multiple accounts, Anna and Marvin remained genuinely close friends after their divorce. She was present at his funeral. She participated in the scattering of his ashes. Whatever the marriage had been, it had left her with something she valued.