The distinction between what is known and what is inferred is the basic epistemological challenge of all journalism about complicated events. The sources for this story are contemporaneous news reports, dealer statements, law enforcement confirming the recovery, and Cage’s single public statement. They are consistent with each other on the main facts—the theft in 2000, the recovery in 2011 from a San Fernando Valley storage locker, the role of Fishler and Hrycyk in the recovery, the insurance issue, the subsequent ComicConnect auction—and inconsistent on secondary details like the exact year of Cage’s purchase. An honest account of the story works within these parameters: confirming what the sources agree on, noting where they differ, and acknowledging where the record is simply silent.
The silence in the record is not a gap to be filled with imagination. The thief is not named; their motives are not described; their subsequent fate is not recounted. The story does not have a villain with a known face or a known name. What it has is a stolen comic, eleven years of investigation, and a recovery that required the right call at the right moment from the right expert. That is sufficient for a story, even without a named culprit and a resolution in court.
—
THE JANUARY 2026 TRANSACTION IN DETAIL
The most recent major market event in the history of this copy—or of the other CGC 9.0 copy, if they are distinct—was the January 2026 private sale for $15 million, publicly announced on January 9, 2026. This transaction represented a new record for any comic book sold to a private buyer, surpassing the previous record of $9.12 million set for a copy of Superman No. 1 in November 2025.