Both versions of the story are true: the told version and the documented version. They overlap substantially. The difference is in the details—in what can be stated confidently and what must be hedged, in what the record establishes and what it merely allows. A story told carefully within those constraints is a story that respects both the facts and the reader’s right to know which is which.
That care is itself a form of respect for the object. A piece of paper that has survived nearly ninety years, that introduced one of the most significant characters in the history of popular culture, that was purchased by a famous actor who understood its meaning, that was stolen and recovered and sold and resold until it commanded $15 million—such an object deserves an account that is as honest as the evidence permits. It deserves to be understood as what it actually is, rather than as the cleaner version of itself that a satisfying narrative would require.
The paper holds the story. The story, faithfully told, holds the paper in the place it has earned.
—
CODA: THE OBJECT AND ITS OWNERS
There is a lineage of ownership attached to this specific copy of Action Comics No. 1 that the available record can trace, partially. Someone bought it new from a newsstand in the spring of 1938 for ten cents—who, and where, are not recorded. It survived decades in conditions and circumstances that are not documented. It appeared at a Sotheby’s auction in 1992, where it sold for more than $82,000. Stephen Fishler of Metropolis Collectibles acquired it and sold it to Nicolas Cage in the mid-1990s for $150,000. Cage’s home was burglarized in 2000 and the comic disappeared. For eleven years it was in the possession of persons unknown, in circumstances unknown, and then it was in a storage locker in the San Fernando Valley, and then it was in the hands of an auction buyer who brought it to Mark Balelo, who called Fishler, who called Detective Hrycyk, and the comic was secured as evidence, and eventually returned to Cage, and sold at ComicConnect for $2.16 million in November 2011, and has since changed hands at least once, possibly more, and as of January 2026, one copy of Action Comics No. 1 in CGC 9.0 condition was sold privately for $15 million.