NCMEC’s recognition of this use case — the fact that adults questioning their identity might be the very missing children whose cases are on file — shaped how the organization thought about its public communications. The website’s design and the guidance it provides are intended in part to serve exactly this kind of inquiry. An adult who suspects they might be a missing person can search the database, examine the listings, and follow a pathway toward official contact and DNA verification.

Carlina White did this without a formal protocol telling her to. She did it through years of incremental searching, through the persistent awareness that something about her identity did not match what she had been told, and through the specific detail of a birthmark on an arm in a photograph from 1987. When she saw that photograph, she did not call a friend or post about it online. She called NCMEC.

—

## The Lifetime Movie and the Line Between Story and Fact

In 2012, Lifetime aired “Abducted: The Carlina White Story,” a dramatization of the events described in this article. The film depicted the abduction, Carlina’s childhood, her process of self-discovery, and the reunion with her birth family.

Dramatizations of real criminal cases occupy a specific and sometimes problematic space in public understanding. A film made for television, with actors and scripted dialogue, inevitably fills in the gaps of what is documented — giving characters thoughts, words, and motivations that the historical record does not establish. For Carlina’s story, which has numerous documented gaps (her inner experience of her childhood, the specific dynamics of her household with Pettway, the texture of the 2011 reunion), a dramatic treatment necessarily invents the connective tissue.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.