The confirmation bias also played a role. The *Supper at Emmaus* did not simply match Vermeer’s style in ways that Bredius recognized. It confirmed a specific theory Bredius had already developed about Vermeer’s development — the Italian trip, the missing religious phase, the Caravaggesque influence. When a painting confirms a scholar’s existing interpretation of an artist, the scholar is predisposed to find that painting convincing. The forgery was not simply good enough to pass inspection. It was targeted at the specific intellectual framework that would make its examiner most receptive.

Other scholars followed Bredius’s lead. His Burlington Magazine article, published in November 1937, carried his authority throughout the field. Major Vermeer scholarship subsequently incorporated the Emmaus into accounts of the painter’s development. The painting existed in the institutional record, in the museum, authenticated by the most respected name in the field. The incentive to challenge an authentication of that provenance was low, and the standard of evidence required to overturn it was high.

—

## More Forgeries, More Millions

The success of the Emmaus changed van Meegeren’s plan. He had originally intended to reveal the fraud — to publish his confession after Bredius had praised it, to expose the connoisseur establishment as credulous gatekeepers. He did not do this. Looking at 520,000 guilders and the ease with which the system had been fooled, he decided to continue.

He used the money from the Emmaus acquisition to fund a life in Nice — a villa, fine living, the trappings of a wealthy aesthete. And he continued producing forgeries.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.