In 1937, Abraham Bredius — the most respected Vermeer authority in the world — stood before a painting he had never seen before and declared it one of the greatest discoveries in the history of Dutch art. He wrote about it in the *Burlington Magazine*. He donated his own money so a Dutch museum could buy it. The painting hung in the Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen in Rotterdam as a confirmed masterpiece by Johannes Vermeer. Art historians wrote about it. Scholars adjusted their understanding of Vermeer’s development as a painter to accommodate what it seemed to show. The acquisition was celebrated.

Eight years later, a Dutch forger named Han van Meegeren confessed that he had painted it himself.

—

## The 1937 Discovery That Was Not a Discovery

The painting is called *Christ and the Disciples at Emmaus* — also known as the *Supper at Emmaus*. It depicts the moment from the Gospel of Luke when Jesus appears to two disciples on the road to Emmaus after the resurrection, breaking bread with them, the act of breaking bread revealing who he is. It is a subject with a long tradition in Western religious painting. Caravaggio painted his version. Rembrandt painted his. And in 1937, the art world believed Vermeer had painted his.

The story of how the painting was brought to Bredius follows a pattern that van Meegeren would refine across multiple forgeries. A lawyer presented the work as belonging to an Italian family of Dutch descent who needed to sell it quietly, without attracting attention that might invite fascist scrutiny. The provenance was vague by design. The family wished to remain anonymous. This was the kind of story that explained why a masterpiece had remained unknown for so long without raising suspicion — a family holding a painting in private for generations, only now forced by circumstances to part with it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.