Abraham Bredius was 83 years old when he was shown the painting. He had spent decades establishing himself as the foremost authority on the Dutch Golden Age, particularly on Rembrandt and Vermeer. He had made genuine major discoveries earlier in his career. His authentication carried a weight in the art world that was not merely professional but almost canonical — colleagues had taken to calling him “the Pope.” His word on a Vermeer was, effectively, the last word.
Bredius examined the painting and was convinced. His article in the *Burlington Magazine*, published in November 1937, described the experience in terms that suggested genuine excitement barely contained by academic caution. He called it “the masterpiece of Johannes Vermeer of Delft.” He noted the painting’s stylistic consistency with the two religious works then accepted as genuine Vermeers — *Christ in the House of Martha and Mary* (c. 1654–55, Scottish National Gallery, Edinburgh) and *Diana and Her Companions* (c. 1653–56, Mauritshuis, The Hague) — and argued it showed Italian influence consistent with the theory that Vermeer had been to Italy and worked through a religious phase early in his career. He pointed to what he identified as characteristic Vermeer details: the light falling from the left, the *pointillés* — small dabs of bright paint — on the bread, and the specific palette of blue and gold.
He did not conduct scientific analysis. He applied the connoisseur’s eye — the method of attribution that relied on trained visual judgment to match a work’s style, handling, and details against an accumulated knowledge of a master’s authentic production. For centuries, this was how attributions were made. For the specific painting that van Meegeren had produced, the connoisseur’s eye was not adequate.
