—
## The Gap in the Catalogue
To understand why Bredius was convinced, it helps to understand the specific argument the painting made.
By 1937, the accepted catalogue of Vermeer’s work was relatively small — fewer than forty paintings that scholars agreed were genuine. Of those, only two depicted religious subjects. The rest were the domestic interior scenes — women reading letters, women playing instruments, women weighing pearls, the carefully controlled flood of light from a window on the left of the room — that defined the popular image of Vermeer and had made him one of the most admired painters of the Golden Age since his rediscovery in the mid-nineteenth century.
This smallness of the catalogue created a specific intellectual opportunity. If Vermeer was capable of the domestic interiors he certainly painted, what had he done before he reached that mature style? A common assumption among art historians was that Vermeer had spent time in Italy, as many Dutch painters of his generation did, absorbing the influence of Italian masters — particularly Caravaggio, whose chiaroscuro technique, the high drama of light against darkness, had transformed European painting in the early seventeenth century. But there was no Italian religious work in the accepted catalogue. The gap implied a missing phase, and the missing phase implied missing paintings.
Van Meegeren had identified this gap before he began his preparation for the forgery. He understood that the most effective forgery of Vermeer would not attempt to replicate the domestic interiors everyone knew. It would instead fill the gap — produce a large-scale religious painting in a style that was visually consistent with the domestic Vermeers but showed the Italian influence that the theory predicted and the missing period would explain. If the painting confirmed a hypothesis that serious scholars had already advanced, those scholars were more likely to believe it.
