The confession did not resolve his legal situation. It complicated it. If the works were genuine, he had collaborated. If they were forgeries, he had committed a different set of crimes — fraud, deception — but not collaboration. His interrogators and the art experts they consulted did not simply take his word for it.
He was detained in a government-rented house under police guard while the question was investigated. And there, under supervision, he began to paint a new forgery in Vermeer’s style — the work that became known as *Jesus Among the Doctors* (sometimes called *Young Christ in the Temple*). He painted from July to December 1945, using witnesses and press photographers as observers. He painted Vermeer’s manner — the light, the palette, the textures — using the same materials and techniques he had developed over years of preparation.
The demonstration painting served a specific evidential purpose: if van Meegeren could produce a work in Vermeer’s style under controlled observation, using the methods he claimed to have used for his earlier forgeries, it established that those earlier forgeries were technically within his capabilities. It was not, by itself, proof that the contested works in public collections were his forgeries rather than genuine Old Masters — the logical step of identifying his specific forgeries required chemical analysis, not just the demonstration that he could paint in a Vermeer style. But it was persuasive evidence that his claim should be taken seriously.
The press coverage of the demonstration was extensive. Van Meegeren, who had spent his career failing to attract public attention to his work as an original artist, was suddenly the most discussed painter in the Netherlands. The newspapers covered the demonstration. Public opinion shifted. Where the authorities had been skeptical, the public was fascinated — and increasingly sympathetic.
