The canvas fragment that van Meegeren had kept from the Emmaus painting was matched to the canvas of the painting at the Boijmans — a physical connection between the forger and the work that had been hanging as a Vermeer in the museum’s collection for years.

The 1947 trial of van Meegeren was therefore not, primarily, a question of whether he had forged the works. By the time the trial began, the scientific evidence established that the contested paintings contained twentieth-century materials. The demonstration painting had shown that van Meegeren was capable of producing convincing Old Master-style work. The question before the court was the nature and extent of the fraud and the appropriate sentence.

—

## The Trial of 1947

The trial opened on October 29, 1947, in Amsterdam’s Regional Court. The charge that had led to van Meegeren’s initial arrest — collaboration — had been set aside in favor of the demonstrably accurate charge of fraud and forgery. The court was asked to assess a career of deliberate deception that had extended over approximately a decade and had involved the sale of multiple fake works to buyers including major museums and one of the Netherlands’ wealthiest private collectors.

Van Meegeren presented his case with the flair of a man who had spent two years becoming famous for the story he was telling. He argued that his motivations were not simply financial. He had forged the paintings to prove his worth as an artist and to expose the critics and connoisseurs who had rejected his legitimate work as derivative. The *Supper at Emmaus*, in particular, had succeeded beyond any other single painting he could have produced as an original work — it had been acquired by a museum, authenticated by the most respected expert in the field, and celebrated by the art world. The fact that it was a forgery was, in his telling, the point. He had proven that he could surpass Vermeer in the eyes of the men who claimed to be Vermeer’s greatest living authorities.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.