What is established is that the success of the Emmaus depended on the painting being convincing to a specific audience with specific expectations and desires at a specific historical moment. A forgery that required the audience to want it to be genuine is not simply a technical achievement. It is also a form of social intelligence — an accurate reading of an audience’s psychological situation and a deliberate construction of an object that exploits it.

—

## Dirk Hannema and the Weight of a Wrong Attribution

Dirk Hannema, the Boijmans director who had overseen the Emmaus acquisition with such enthusiasm, found himself in a complicated position after van Meegeren’s confession.

He had not simply trusted Bredius’s authentication at a distance. He had been an active participant in the acquisition — seeking funding, coordinating donors, celebrating the painting as a highlight of his institution. His professional reputation was directly invested in the Emmaus being what Bredius said it was.

After the Liberation, Hannema faced legal proceedings of his own. He was arrested and interned for eight months on charges related to the illegal sale of artworks to the Germans during the occupation. He was released in 1947 without formal conviction, but he was dismissed from the Boijmans Museum.

His later career suggests a man who found it difficult to accept the implications of institutional attribution errors. In 1975 he insisted that a painting he had acquired was an authentic Van Gogh, despite widespread skepticism — a position that remained controversial until the Van Gogh Museum’s 2010 authentication of the work suggested, at least in that specific case, that his judgment had been correct. His career after the Boijmans was bound up with the question of whether expertise and experience could be trusted when institutions had already been shown to fail.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.