Reversing such an attribution, even with strong evidence, is not merely a technical task. It is a social and institutional act that requires overcoming inertia, defending a challenge against the holders of the authority being challenged, and accepting the costs — financial, reputational, professional — of having been wrong. The buyers and institutions that had paid for van Meegeren’s forgeries did not eagerly accept the news that they had been deceived. Van Beuningen sued the man who told him. Hannema’s later career was partly defined by his resistance to accepting what his acquisition had turned out to be.
The lesson for how museums and auction houses now handle attribution is not simply “do more scientific testing,” though that is part of it. It is also that the social structure of attribution — the way that an authoritative pronouncement creates institutional momentum that subsequent evidence must overcome — is itself a vulnerability that forgeries are designed to exploit. Van Meegeren did not just make a convincing painting. He made a painting that became, through the machinery of institutional validation, increasingly difficult to doubt.
—
## The Emmaus Today: A Document of Its Own History
The *Supper at Emmaus* by Han van Meegeren, oil on a seventeenth-century canvas, painted approximately 1936, acquired by the Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen 1937–1939, is currently held in storage in the museum’s depot in Rotterdam.
It is not a Vermeer. It never was. The paint contains phenol formaldehyde resin that did not exist in the seventeenth century. The canvas beneath it holds the traces of a painting that van Meegeren scrubbed away. The *pointillés* on the bread were painted by a man who had spent six years learning how to put them there convincingly, in a villa in the south of France, with badger-hair brushes and a medium of dissolved synthetic resin.
