The composition itself, while van Meegeren’s invention, drew on the specific visual language of Vermeer’s authenticated works — the left-side light source, the restrained palette, the specific relationship between figure and space. These choices were not generic imitations of seventeenth-century Dutch painting. They were targeted responses to what the scholarship had established as characteristic of a specific painter. Van Meegeren was not imitating Vermeer. He was constructing a Vermeer — building from the inside out, from the theoretical framework toward the visible surface.
—
## The Question of Anachronism in the Forgeries
One of the more striking aspects of the van Meegeren case, viewed from the perspective of later forensic analysis, is that several of the anachronisms that exposed the forgeries were potentially detectable before the exposure.
Cobalt blue — the pigment found in two of van Meegeren’s forgeries — was developed in the early nineteenth century by the French chemist Louis-Jacques Thénard. It became commercially available in 1807. It was not available in the seventeenth century. Any examiner who had tested the blue pigment in the contested paintings before van Meegeren’s confession would have found this.
The phenol formaldehyde resin — the Bakelite medium that hardened the paint and allowed it to pass the needle test — was first synthesized by Leo Baekeland in 1907 and commercialized in the early 1910s. Its presence in the paint of a “Vermeer” was physically impossible if the painting was what it was claimed to be.
Both anachronisms were theoretically detectable. Neither was detected until after the confession, because neither examination was performed. The standard procedure for authenticating a major Old Master work in the 1930s did not include chemical analysis of pigments as a routine step. The assumption was that the connoisseur’s eye, properly applied, was sufficient. Chemical analysis was not a standard part of the protocol.
