That was exactly what had happened, as the chemical analysis confirmed. The resistance of the experts was understandable, but it was wrong. And their insistence, after van Meegeren’s confession, that the works must be genuine — their testimony that the contested Vermeers showed the master’s hand — contributed to a trial in which the chemical evidence was essential precisely because the expert consensus was still, as late as 1947, divided.

The chemical evidence — the phenol formaldehyde resin, the cobalt blue, the canvas evidence — was not subject to the kind of authority-based argument that had sustained the false attributions. It was physical evidence. It said what it said regardless of what any expert believed. And it was, ultimately, what convicted van Meegeren and confirmed his claims.

—

## Van Meegeren’s Self-Presentation

Throughout his period of detention and his trial, van Meegeren was an active and skillful manager of his own public image. The story he told about himself was coherent, internally consistent, and compelling, even where it was incomplete or self-serving.

He presented himself as an artist who had been wronged by the establishment. The critics who had dismissed his work as derivative had, he argued, proven their own incompetence by failing to recognize his abilities — abilities that were directly demonstrated by the success of the forgeries. The experts who had authenticated his work as Vermeer’s were the same experts who had dismissed his original work as lacking originality. His forgeries, by this account, were a form of revenge as much as a crime: proof that the gatekeepers of the art world were not qualified to judge what they were judging.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.