—
## The 1967 Lead-210 Dating: Scientific Closure
The van Meegeren case had been legally resolved by 1947, but the question of whether specific contested works were genuinely his forgeries or authentic Old Masters continued to circulate in certain quarters long after the conviction. The chemical analysis that Coremans had conducted was thorough and the evidence was strong, but some skeptics — including art historians with professional investments in the attributions — continued to question specific aspects of the forensic conclusions.
In 1967, a team at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh published the results of a study applying lead-210 radioactive dating to white lead pigment from a selection of contested paintings. The technique measured the residual concentration of a specific radioactive isotope — lead-210 — in white lead pigment, exploiting the fact that the ore processing that produces white lead removes a chemically related element (radium-226), causing the lead-210 to begin decaying at a known rate from the moment of processing.
If white lead pigment was processed in the seventeenth century and used in a painting shortly after, the amount of lead-210 remaining in the pigment in 1967 would reflect three-hundred-plus years of decay. If the pigment was processed in the twentieth century, the residual lead-210 concentration would be much higher — reflecting only decades of decay rather than centuries.
The Carnegie Mellon results were unambiguous. The white lead in the contested paintings showed lead-210 concentrations consistent with twentieth-century processing — not with seventeenth-century manufacturing. The paintings were not three hundred years old in their materials. The chemical and radioactive evidence converged on the same conclusion that van Meegeren’s own confession and the Coremans investigation had established: the paintings were modern.
