The focus of most accounts of the van Meegeren case falls on the forger, on his technical achievement, on the cleverness of his methods, on the exposure of the experts’ credulity. This focus, understandable as a matter of narrative interest, tends to displace attention from the victims of the fraud.

The buyers who paid for van Meegeren’s forgeries were not all equally sympathetic figures. D.G. van Beuningen was one of the richest men in the Netherlands; the guilders he lost to van Meegeren represented a small fraction of his wealth and were, in a narrow sense, the cost of participation in a market he was sophisticated enough to understand. Hermann Göring was not a sympathetic victim at all — he was a war criminal who had looted Dutch cultural property on an enormous scale, and the painting he received in exchange for his stolen goods was worthless paper, which the Dutch public found, understandably, satisfying.

But the institutional buyers present a different picture. The Rijksmuseum’s purchase of the *Washing of the Feet* in 1943 — approximately 900,000 guilders — was a purchase of public funds. The museum used Dutch public money to buy a forgery. The Stichting Rembrandt’s contribution to the Emmaus acquisition — the foundation that existed specifically to help Dutch museums acquire important national cultural heritage — was money donated for a public purpose, spent on a fake. Bredius’s personal donation of approximately 90,000 guilders to the Emmaus acquisition was his own money, given in support of a painting he believed was a Vermeer.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.