The specific mechanism that propagated the fraud was the same mechanism that makes the art market function in normal circumstances: the reliance on established reputation, on institutional authority, on the track record of previous transactions. These are rational mechanisms for reducing uncertainty in a market where authentic information is scarce. They are also, precisely because of their rationality, mechanisms that a sophisticated forger can exploit.

The reform of authentication practice after the van Meegeren case — the increased use of physical and chemical analysis, the development of multi-method approaches to attribution — addressed some of these structural vulnerabilities. But the underlying structure of the market, with its concentration of authority and its reliance on reputation cascades, remained, and later cases of sophisticated forgery demonstrated that it remained exploitable. The van Meegeren case was not the last major forgery case; it was the first major case in which the forensic tools to expose a systematic forgery were fully deployed. Subsequent cases — the Elmyr de Hory forgeries, the Wolfgang Beltracchi case of the early twenty-first century — showed that the specific methods had changed but the structural vulnerabilities had not been fully eliminated.

—

## The Göring Transaction and the Ethics of Reverse Deception

The specific detail of the Göring transaction — that van Meegeren sold a worthless forgery to the head of the Luftwaffe in exchange for stolen Dutch paintings — has attracted more ethical analysis than almost any other aspect of the case.

Van Meegeren presented the transaction as a form of resistance: he had given Göring nothing of value while taking back, in the form of Dutch paintings, something that the occupation had removed from the Netherlands. This argument has real force, and it explains the warmth of the Dutch public’s response to van Meegeren’s story in 1945. The image of a Dutch civilian tricking a Nazi official through superior cunning was, in the immediate postwar period, deeply satisfying.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.