The Dutch public’s enthusiasm for the van Meegeren story in 1945 was not simply enthusiasm for a clever forger. It was, in part, a response to a story that offered a form of cultural satisfaction in a period that offered very little. A Dutch civilian had taken a Nazi for an enormous sum. The art world establishment — the connoisseurs and critics who had dismissed Dutch artists while celebrating Old Masters — had been shown to be fools. The story was satisfying in ways that went beyond the immediate facts.

The public opinion poll that placed van Meegeren second in national popularity in 1947 — after the Prime Minister and ahead of figures who had genuinely resisted the occupation — reflects the specific cultural moment of its collection. It was not a verdict on the totality of van Meegeren’s actions. It was a snapshot of a public response to a particular story at a particular moment, shaped by the specific emotional needs of a society in the immediate aftermath of occupation and war.

His actual legacy in Dutch cultural history is more complicated. He demonstrated, more dramatically than any previous case, the specific vulnerabilities of the connoisseurial authentication system. He enriched himself at the expense of Dutch public institutions. He exploited the wartime disruption of the Dutch art market for personal gain. And he created, in the *Supper at Emmaus* and the other forgeries, objects that Dutch institutions have grappled with ever since — not as masterpieces but as documents of a specific historical event.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.