The museum — and the broader art world — had bought something it did not understand it was buying. It had bought a physical object that satisfied all the criteria it knew how to apply, produced by someone who had studied those criteria specifically to satisfy them. What it had not bought — could not have bought, because it did not know how to look for it — was the evidence of the painting’s actual origin.
The label on the painting at the Boijmans now reads differently than it read in 1937. The painting did not change. The knowledge about it did. That is what the van Meegeren case ultimately illustrates: knowledge is not simply accumulated; it is revised. And the revision of an attribution — the change of a name in a label — can transform what an object means to everyone who looks at it, without touching a single atom of the paint.
The *Supper at Emmaus* remains in its depot, a forgery that was once a masterpiece, a document that was once a discovery. It is exactly what it was the day van Meegeren finished baking it in his oven in Roquebrune. What changed was everything else.
—
## The Notebooks, the Studio, and What Was Found in Nice
After van Meegeren’s arrest, Dutch and Allied investigators examined his properties and his working materials. What they found provided much of the physical evidence for the case, and also offered a window into how methodically he had prepared.
His studio in Nice — and later his Amsterdam house — contained materials that documented the specific processes he had used. Bottles of Albertol, the phenol formaldehyde resin product he had used as a binding medium. Pigments prepared in historical formulas. Badger-hair brushes of the type he had identified as appropriate for Vermeer’s technique. Canvases in various stages of preparation, including works that he had not completed or not attempted to sell — the *Woman Reading Music* and the *Woman Playing the Lute* were found unsold.
