It is, as a document of its own history, more interesting than many genuine Vermeers. It is a physical record of an extraordinary act of deception, carried out with unusual skill and unusual preparation, sustained over years in ways that implicated the most credible institutions and most authoritative individuals in the Dutch art world. It is evidence of what expert knowledge cannot see when it is not looking in the right direction, and of what physical science can find when it asks the right questions.

The paint on the canvas is the same paint that van Meegeren applied. The craquelure is the craquelure he created by rolling the baked canvas over a cylinder. The *pointillés* on the bread are the dabs he placed there knowing that Bredius would see them and think of Vermeer. All of this is known, documented, confirmed by converging lines of evidence that allow no reasonable alternative interpretation.

The painting that is currently in storage in the Boijmans depot is exactly what it appears to be: a document of a moment in the history of Dutch art, of the history of expertise and its limits, and of the specific story of one man who decided to prove something to a world that had dismissed him, and who succeeded so completely that the proof itself became his problem.

—

## The Persistence of the Question

Scholars and curators who work with the van Meegeren forgeries today occupy an unusual position: they possess objects that are entirely authenticated, fully documented, and completely understood in terms of their physical composition and historical origin — and yet those objects continue to generate interpretive questions that the documentation does not resolve.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.