The forger who made it died in 1947, before he served a single day of his sentence. The painting he made continues to outlast the judgment passed on it, sitting in its depot, exactly what it is, waiting for the next question.

—

## The Position of Skeptics and Why Some Held On

After van Meegeren’s public confession and the publication of Coremans’s findings, most of the scholarly and institutional world accepted the evidence. But a small number of people — primarily those with the strongest professional investment in the original attributions — continued to resist the conclusion for years.

Their resistance took different forms. D.G. van Beuningen’s lawsuit against Coremans was the most dramatic: a legal challenge to the scientific findings that represented both personal conviction and financial desperation. Van Beuningen had spent more money on van Meegeren’s forgeries than any other single buyer. Accepting their worthlessness was not simply an intellectual concession. It was an acknowledgment of an enormous financial and reputational loss.

Some scholars raised specific technical objections to Coremans’s methodology, arguing that the presence of synthetic resins in the paint could have resulted from a later restoration or conservation treatment rather than from van Meegeren’s original application. This was a theoretically possible alternative explanation, and Coremans’s report addressed it — the distribution of the resin through the paint layers was inconsistent with surface-applied conservation treatment and consistent with original inclusion in the binding medium. But the objection illustrated the structure of motivated resistance: the goal was not to identify the most likely explanation of the evidence but to find any alternative explanation, however strained, that preserved the original attribution.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.