Future investigators working on this case will have better tools than any investigator has had before. Mass spectrometry techniques that were not available in 1947 can now identify individual molecules in microgram-scale paint samples. Neutron activation analysis can establish the geological provenance of specific minerals used in pigments, potentially establishing where specific materials were sourced. Computational image analysis can compare the specific handling of paint across works at a resolution that the human eye cannot achieve.
Whether any of these advances will produce new findings about the van Meegeren forgeries is uncertain. The core questions about the contested works are answered. But the broader question of whether other works that have not been connected to van Meegeren might be identified as his through more sensitive analysis — the question of the full scope of his output — remains theoretically open.
What the archive does not preserve, and what the documentary record cannot reconstruct, is the subjective experience of standing before the *Supper at Emmaus* in the Boijmans in 1938 and believing it was a Vermeer. That experience — the specific quality of conviction that the painting produced in its first viewers, the specific nature of what it meant to them to see what they believed was a major discovery — is irretrievably lost. We can read Bredius’s words in the Burlington Magazine. We cannot see what he saw when he saw the painting, because what he saw was partly a function of what he believed, and what he believed was wrong.
The painting is there. The experience is gone. This, too, is part of what the case teaches: that the objects we study are not fully separable from the beliefs and contexts of those who have encountered them, and that some of what a work means to its contemporaries cannot be recovered by later investigators, however comprehensive their tools.
