What is not disputed is that people were alive in the tunnel who would not have been alive if the hoods had not been used, and that the two previous rescue attempts without protection had failed and added to the death toll.
—
## Frank Morgan’s Role
Garrett Morgan’s brother Frank accompanied him into the tunnel and deserves specific recognition in the historical record, which often elides him in favor of focusing exclusively on Garrett.
Frank went in with Garrett on the initial descent. He was wearing one of the hoods. He performed the same physical work of rescue — advancing into gas-filled darkness, identifying survivors, bringing them back. He made multiple trips.
The specific details of Frank’s contributions relative to Garrett’s are not fully elaborated in the accessible sources. The accounts that credit specific individuals with specific rescues typically focus on Garrett as the leader of the rescue party and the inventor of the device. Frank appears in most accounts as a supporting figure — essential but supporting.
This pattern in the sources likely reflects both the newspaper and institutional coverage that the disaster received and the subsequent historical attention that focused on Garrett as the inventor. The Carnegie Hero Fund’s nomination process, which ultimately rejected the Morgan nomination, was submitted for Garrett; whether Frank was separately nominated is not documented in accessible sources.
The two volunteers who accompanied the brothers on some descents are even less documented. Their names appear in some accounts without consistent identification. The rescue was a collective effort, and the men who entered the tunnel alongside the Morgans performed the same courageous work under the same conditions.
