On November 13, 1961, an oil tanker named the *Gulf Lion* came across a small dinghy drifting in the Northwest Providence Channel, about forty miles northwest of Nassau in the Bahamas. A man sat in the dinghy. He was alive, apparently calm, and he held the body of a small girl in his arms. The girl, he said, was dead. The man was Julian Harvey, 44, captain of the ketch *Bluebelle*, and he told the tanker’s crew that his boat had gone down in a sudden squall the night before. His wife, he said, was gone. The family he had been hired to sail — a husband, wife, and three children from Green Bay, Wisconsin — were gone. Only the little girl had come up on the dinghy with him, and she had not survived.
The crew of the *Gulf Lion* had no reason to doubt him. Harvey was a decorated military veteran, a Fort Lauderdale yachtsman of considerable reputation, and he answered their questions in an orderly, coherent way. He was taken aboard and transported to Nassau, then returned to Miami, where he gave a formal statement to U.S. Coast Guard investigators.
Three days later, on November 16, 1961, a Greek freighter named the *Captain Theo* was sailing through the same general region of the Bahamas when a lookout spotted something white in the water. The crew investigated. What they found was an eleven-year-old girl, alone on a small cork float, badly sunburned and severely dehydrated, drifting in the open ocean. She had been there for approximately three and a half days. She was barely alive.
