The recognition Morgan received during his lifetime was always partial and always inadequate to what he had done. The recognition that has accumulated since his death is more complete, though it arrives too late to reach him.

 

—

 

## The Hood: What It Was and Was Not

 

A note of technical precision is warranted about the safety hood, because popular accounts sometimes describe it in ways that overstate its capabilities.

 

The Morgan safety hood protected wearers in smoke-filled environments and spaces where oxygen levels were reduced — the specific conditions common in structural fires and certain industrial accidents. It drew cleaner air from near the floor level, used a wet sponge to filter particulate matter, and in its later versions incorporated a reservoir of fresh air. These were meaningful and effective protections for the specific environments the device was designed for.

 

It was not a gas mask in the full sense of that term as it developed in the military context of World War I and after. The military gas mask used activated charcoal and other filtering media to adsorb specific chemical agents — chlorine, phosgene, cyanide, mustard — that were deployed as weapons. Morgan’s device did not include this type of chemical filtering and would not have provided protection against warfare gases or other chemical hazards that operated through chemical rather than oxygen-displacement mechanisms.

 

The Cleveland waterworks tunnel in July 1916 was filled primarily with natural gas — methane and related hydrocarbons — that displaced oxygen and created an asphyxiation risk rather than a chemical toxicity risk. For this specific environment, Morgan’s device was appropriate and effective. The fact that it worked in the tunnel does not establish that it would work in all gas-filled environments, and descriptions of it as a universal gas mask go beyond what the available evidence supports.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.