—
## The Mechanics of the Disaster: Gas and Tunnel Physics
Understanding what happened in the Cleveland waterworks tunnel on July 24-25, 1916, requires some attention to the specific physics and chemistry of the situation.
The tunnel was running through sedimentary rock beneath the floor of Lake Erie. The rock layers under the lake contain natural gas that has accumulated in porous formations over geological time — the same geology that makes Ohio part of a broader region of Appalachian Basin oil and gas deposits. When a tunnel face advances into a rock layer that contains such a pocket, the gas enters the tunnel space.
Natural gas is primarily methane, with smaller amounts of ethane, propane, and other hydrocarbons. It is not toxic in the way that carbon monoxide is toxic; its primary danger is flammable — it ignites and explodes in the right air-to-gas ratio — and asphyxiating at high concentrations, because it displaces oxygen. In an enclosed space, a large release of natural gas rapidly reduces the oxygen concentration to below the level required for consciousness and life.
The ignition that occurred on July 24 produced both effects. The immediate explosion killed the workers at the tunnel face — the blast and heat were immediately lethal to anyone in close proximity. The gas that continued to flow into the tunnel created the asphyxiation hazard that killed the subsequent rescue parties. The gas was invisible in the dark tunnel; there was no warning before unconsciousness.
The specific challenge this created for rescue was that the hazard could not be seen or smelled with enough warning to turn back. The unprotected rescue parties that entered the tunnel were not being reckless; they were entering a space where the gas concentration was not necessarily immediately apparent, where it was possible to advance some distance before the effects became apparent, and where retreat once the effects began was likely too late.
