The claim of nine lives does not match any of the figures given in the other accessible sources — neither the two directly attributed to Morgan by the Carnegie Fund’s investigation, nor the eight total survivors mentioned in multiple accounts, nor any other specific number. Nine may reflect Morgan’s own count of the people he personally brought out or retrieved over multiple descents; it may reflect a claim that overstates what third-party investigation would support; it may reflect a different count of what constitutes “saving” someone (perhaps including people who were brought out by other rescuers using his hoods, which he had provided and trained others to use).

 

The diary entry is significant not for its specific number but for what it reveals about how Morgan understood what he had done. He did not say “we saved” or “the rescue saved”; he said “I have personally saved.” He was claiming credit for a specific, personal achievement. This directness — asserting his own role and contribution — is consistent with the other documented instances of his self-advocacy: writing to the mayor, organizing the community, building the newspaper, speaking clearly about what had been withheld from him.

 

The diary entry was written in a private document, not in a letter to an official or a statement for publication. It represents what he thought when he was not performing for an audience or navigating the racial politics of public acknowledgment. He believed he had saved nine lives. Whatever the precise historical count establishes, the belief was genuine and the basis for it was real.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.