—
## The Men Who Didn’t Come Back: The Human Cost
The deaths in the July 24-25 disaster — the workers at the tunnel face, the rescuers who went in without protection — are the foundation on which the rescue story sits. It is easy, in accounts that focus on Morgan’s actions and their aftermath, to treat the casualties as a backdrop rather than as the central human reality.
The workers who died at the tunnel face were people. They had names, families, histories. The sandhog community in Cleveland and across the Great Lakes industrial region was a specific occupational culture with its own traditions and identities. The men who worked the underground shifts on the waterworks tunnel extension were skilled workers doing a job that paid relatively well for the period precisely because it was dangerous.
The rescuers who died in the first and second parties were also people who had made a choice — the same fundamental choice Morgan made, without the protection he had. They went in because men were down and needed to be brought out, because that is what rescuers do, because the possibility that someone could be saved justified the risk. The fact that they died does not diminish the choice they made.
Their names are not consistently preserved in the accessible sources for this article. John Johnston and Gus Van Duzen are named — Johnston as leader of the first failed rescue party, Van Duzen as leader of the second. Van Duzen was brought out alive by Morgan’s party; Johnston’s fate is not separately documented in accessible sources.
