This is not complete compensation. The honors cannot undo the financial cost of the canceled orders, cannot restore the Carnegie Award and its monetary component, cannot give Morgan the specific forms of recognition and their material consequences that were withheld from him in his prime. They are what they are: a later generation’s attempt to correct a record that was distorted in his lifetime.

 

—

 

## The Specific Technology of the Tunnel’s Construction

 

The waterworks tunnel that the July 1916 disaster struck was being built using the technology available for underwater tunnel construction in the early twentieth century. Understanding the construction environment helps clarify why the gas encounter was both predictable in category and not preventable in the specific instance.

 

The soft-ground tunneling methods of this period included cut-and-cover construction (excavating from above, impractical under a lake) and bored tunneling using a tunnel boring machine or conventional drill-and-blast methods. For a tunnel running more than a hundred feet beneath Lake Erie’s surface, bored construction was the only option.

 

The compressed air method was often used to prevent water infiltration in water-bearing ground: the tunnel was maintained at above-atmospheric pressure, which pushed water out of the porous rock or soil. Workers entered and exited the pressurized zone through airlocks. This method introduced its own hazard — decompression sickness (the bends) if workers depressurized too quickly — but managed the water infiltration problem.

 

The gas hazard the July 1916 crew encountered was different from the water infiltration problem and was not managed by compressed air. Natural gas pockets in the rock responded to tunneling advance as pure geological facts; when the face broke through into a gas-bearing formation, the gas entered the tunnel under whatever pressure existed in the formation. The tunnel’s atmosphere could be overwhelmed in minutes.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.