—

 

## Linking Morgan to the Longer History of Safety

 

The history of worker safety in America is a history of disasters followed by regulation, of deaths followed by investigations, of investigations followed by standards that prevented the specific death from happening the same way again. The Cleveland waterworks tunnel disaster of 1916 fit this pattern imperfectly: it produced a dramatic proof-of-concept for personal air protection equipment but did not immediately produce regulation requiring its use.

 

The regulatory history of tunnel construction safety developed across the twentieth century through the Bureau of Mines (established 1910), state safety departments, and eventually the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (established 1970). The specific standards for tunnel operations — ventilation requirements, gas monitoring, personal protective equipment — developed incrementally through this period.

 

Morgan’s safety hood was part of the broader story of this development: a privately developed technology that demonstrated what was possible before regulatory frameworks existed to require it. The pattern was common: a technology or practice that protected workers from a specific hazard would be developed, demonstrated, and adopted by some employers before regulation required universal adoption, and the gap between voluntary adoption and regulatory mandate could be wide.

 

The gap meant that the protective benefits of the hood — the lives that could have been saved if it had been in widespread use in tunnel operations before 1916 — went unrealized because the market adoption was incomplete and no regulation required its use. How many workers died in tunnel disasters before and after 1916 who might have survived with similar equipment is not calculable from available sources, but the category of death — gas encounter in an unprotected tunnel — was not unique to Cleveland.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.