On the afternoon of October 4, 1918, Major Charles Whittlesey sat in a shallow depression in the Argonne Forest and scratched a message on a slip of paper. His battalion had been surrounded by German forces for two days. American artillery was now shelling his position — friendly fire falling on men who were already under attack from every direction. He had already sent two pigeons with messages asking for the barrage to stop. Neither had succeeded. His third and final bird was a blue-check cock named Cher Ami. Whittlesey wrote: “We are along the road paralell [sic] 276.4. Our artillery is dropping a barrage directly on us. For heavens sake stop it.” Private Omer Richards tied the note to the pigeon’s leg and released it. The bird landed in a nearby tree and refused to fly. The shelling continued.

 

What happened next — the flight, the wounds, the arrival, the shelling’s end — became one of the most repeated stories of the First World War. What actually caused the shelling to stop, and what role the pigeon played in saving the men who survived, is a question that military historians and Smithsonian curators have spent a century trying to answer precisely. The story that settled into public memory was larger, simpler, and more heroic than the documented evidence fully supports. That gap between the event and its legend is itself part of the history.

 

## The 77th Division and the Men Who Became the Lost Battalion

 

The soldiers who entered the Argonne Forest in early October 1918 were not regular Army men. They were draftees, most of them from New York City, organized into the 77th Division. The division had been nicknamed the Metropolitan Division, or sometimes the Times Square Division, in recognition of the urban diversity of its ranks. Its shoulder patch depicted the Statue of Liberty. Its men included immigrants who had come to America from Eastern Europe, Southern Europe, and elsewhere, many of them still speaking the languages of their home countries. Their officers included Wall Street lawyers and Harvard graduates.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.