## The Argonne Forest in 1918
The Argonne was not a wilderness in 1918 in the way a modern reader might imagine. It was managed forest — French timber land that had been worked for centuries — but it was dense enough and rugged enough to make movement difficult and to defeat the kind of coordinated mass assault that might have worked on more open ground.
The ravines that run through the Argonne run roughly east to west, cutting across the direction of the American advance, which was generally north to south. This meant that attacking forces had to cross one ravine and climb one ridgeline after another, in terrain that gave the defenders every advantage. Artillery support was complicated by the difficulty of observing fall of shot through the forest canopy. Infantry coordination became almost impossible once units entered the woods and the terrain separated them.
The Germans had used the years since 1914 to construct a defense in depth throughout the Argonne. The initial positions were the most elaborate, with concrete bunkers and deep wire obstacles. But even the positions further back had been improved and reinforced. German units fighting in the Argonne in October 1918 were defending prepared ground they knew well, against attackers who were navigating unfamiliar terrain in difficult conditions.
The specific location where Whittlesey’s battalion was surrounded — a depression on the northeast slope below the Charlevaux plateau, near the Charlevaux Mill — was ground that the Germans understood well. The surrounding high ground gave German artillery and mortars clear observation of the American position. The ravines that had channeled the American advance into the pocket now worked against any attempt to break out. The men were in a position that was difficult to defend and impossible to reinforce without clearing the surrounding German positions first.
