The nine letters he left in his cabin on the S.S. Toloa when he disappeared have not been made fully public. What they said to their recipients is not part of the public record. His body was never found. The death was ruled a suicide, though the specific circumstances remain undocumented beyond the fact of his disappearance from the ship.

 

He was thirty-six years old. He had survived the Argonne. He had been decorated, promoted, celebrated, and asked to speak about his experience to audiences who wanted to hear the heroic version of the story. The gap between that version and what he had actually experienced appears to have been one that he could not bridge.

 

 

## The Story in Print: How the Legend Was Built, 1919 to 1930

 

The years immediately following the First World War were years of active memory-making, in which the events of 1917 and 1918 were processed, organized, and transmitted to a public that wanted to understand what the war had been. Newspapers, books, films, and official publications all contributed to this process, and the Cher Ami story moved through all of these channels.

 

American newspapers had covered the Lost Battalion during the actual events, to the extent that military censorship and the fog of war allowed. The rescue on October 8, 1918, was reported in the American press within days. Whittlesey’s name, McMurtry’s name, and the basic facts of the encirclement and rescue were public knowledge by the time the armistice was signed in November. The pigeon detail — the last carrier pigeon flying wounded through German fire with the message that stopped the barrage — appeared in early accounts and was quickly amplified.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.