McMurtry returned to New York and to the financial world. He had the social connections, the education, and the temperament to rebuild a civilian life, and he did so successfully. His fortune in the stock market suggests both skill and luck — the market of the 1920s was generous to people who were well-positioned, and McMurtry was well-positioned. He used some of that fortune to organize and fund reunions for the Lost Battalion’s survivors, maintaining the connections that the experience had created.
The reunions were not merely social events. They served the function that veterans’ reunions have always served: they allowed men who shared an experience that most people around them could not understand to spend time with others who had been there. The community of survivors maintained itself through McMurtry’s investment and through the shared identity that the story had given them.
McMurtry lived to 1958, more than three decades after Whittlesey’s death. He was eighty-two years old. The contrast between his longevity and Whittlesey’s disappearance at thirty-six is sharp, though it would be a mistake to draw simple conclusions from it. The survivors of traumatic events do not all respond in the same way, and the factors that determined how each man processed what had happened in the Argonne were multiple and not fully recoverable from the historical record.
The survivors who attended McMurtry’s reunions were themselves aging over those three decades. By the 1940s and 1950s, the men who had been in their twenties in 1918 were in their fifties and sixties. The story they were maintaining was becoming historical — something that had happened before most Americans could remember — even as it remained immediate and personal to them.
