Whittlesey sent runners back toward the American lines to report the situation and request reinforcements. The runners were killed or captured before they could get through. By the morning of October 3, the force was effectively surrounded.
## Inside the Pocket: October 3 and 4
The position the men held was a ravine slope — ground that offered some cover from direct fire but no protection from the artillery and mortars the Germans could bring to bear from surrounding high ground. The American troops dug in as best they could with the tools they had. They had brought their pigeons — a standard part of communications equipment in this phase of the war — and they used them one by one to send messages back to division headquarters.
Pigeons were not a primary communications method by 1918; telephone wire and human runners were more reliable under most conditions. But in a situation where telephone wire could be cut and runners could be killed before getting through, pigeons offered an alternative that the technology of the period could not provide in any other form. A trained carrier pigeon would fly home to its loft regardless of the terrain between the sender and the receiver. It could not be intercepted, could not be intimidated, and did not need to navigate through enemy lines. It was, in a specific set of circumstances, irreplaceable.
Whittlesey’s force had entered the forest with eight pigeons. By the morning of October 4, Private Omer Richards, the battalion’s pigeon handler, had used most of them. Two remained. One was released with a message, and German fire — according to some accounts — struck it in flight, bringing it down before it could reach headquarters.
