The 2021 DNA analysis — conducted by Blazich in collaboration with the National Zoo — resolved one element of the story definitively. The gender question was answerable with modern technology, and the answer was obtained. The more difficult questions — whether the message caused the shelling to stop, when the wounds were sustained, what the Signal Corps records actually establish about the October 4 flight — are questions that the surviving documentation does not fully resolve, and that the Smithsonian now acknowledges as genuinely uncertain.
## What “Nothing Conclusive” Means
Blazich’s conclusion that there is “nothing conclusive” linking Cher Ami to the end of the shelling is a scholar’s precise formulation, and it is worth unpacking what it means and what it does not mean.
It does not mean the flight did not happen. It happened. The Signal Corps records document it. The pigeon was released, was wounded, and arrived at division headquarters.
It does not mean the message was unimportant. Any accurate position message from a surrounded battalion under friendly fire was potentially important. If the message contributed to any subsequent correction, that would be meaningful even if it was not the sole or primary cause of the shelling stopping.
What it means is that the specific causal claim — that Cher Ami’s arrival with the message directly caused the artillery to stop — is not supported by contemporaneous documentation. The timeline problem (the bird arrived after the shelling stopped) is the most direct piece of evidence against the causal claim. The absence of a documented order saying “cease fire because the pigeon arrived” is another. The discrepancy in Army records about when the wounds were sustained raises further questions about whether all the documented details occurred on the same day.
