## Cher Ami in the Century Since

 

The pigeon’s preserved body has been in the Smithsonian since 1921. The story attached to it has circulated through American culture for more than a century. The 2021 reassessment did not end the story; it added a chapter to it.

 

What the reassessment showed, more than anything else, was the durability of legend against documentary revision. The Blazich article appeared in a scholarly journal. It was covered by some popular media outlets. The DNA findings about Cher Ami’s sex were reported more widely. But the basic outline of the story — wounded pigeon, lost battalion, message, rescue — continues to be the version most widely encountered by most people.

 

This durability is not unique to the Cher Ami story. It is a general feature of historical legend. The stories that become entrenched in popular culture are entrenched because they serve functions that accurate but complicated accounts cannot serve as well. They teach something — about courage, about sacrifice, about the unexpected — in a form that is memorable and emotionally accessible. Revising them requires not just new evidence but a new story that can serve the same functions while being more accurate.

 

The Smithsonian is in a better position than most institutions to revise the story, because it controls the physical artifact and because it has the institutional authority to frame the account for visitors. The 2021 DNA analysis demonstrated this capacity: the gender question was asked, researched, and answered definitively. The more difficult questions about causation and timing are less amenable to resolution by laboratory analysis, but they can be — and have been — acknowledged as uncertain rather than presented as settled.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.