## The Draftee Army and Its Achievement

 

The Lost Battalion was composed primarily of drafted men, and the fact of their draft status was not incidental to how the story was received in 1918 and after.

 

The United States had relied on a volunteer army for most of its history, and the institution of the draft for the First World War was a significant change. The men of the 77th Division had not volunteered for service; they had been required to serve. Some of them may have wanted to be in the Army; many of them may not have. The question of whether drafted men could fight as effectively as volunteers was a live question in 1917 and 1918, and the answer would shape the future of American military organization.

 

The Lost Battalion provided an answer, of a kind. Men who had been drafted from New York City, many of them immigrants or the children of immigrants, speaking English with the accents of other languages, had been surrounded in a French forest for five days, refused to surrender, and endured until relief came. The 107 who died in that position were draftees. The 190 who walked out were draftees. They had performed as well, under the same extreme conditions, as any volunteer force could have been expected to perform.

 

The story’s reception in New York reflected this dimension. The 77th Division had been formed from men of the city, and the city felt a specific connection to the Lost Battalion. The immigrants and sons of immigrants who had made up a substantial portion of the division’s ranks had demonstrated, through five days in the Argonne, that they were Americans in the full sense — willing to die for the country, capable of enduring what that country’s wars required of them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.