The psychological pressure of encirclement — knowing that you are surrounded, that relief is uncertain, that the enemy can attack from any direction, that your own side may not know exactly where you are — is a specific kind of stress that is difficult to describe. The surrender demand on October 7 was partly an attempt to exploit this pressure, to persuade men who had been under sustained stress that their situation was hopeless and that rational calculation argued for giving up.

 

The men did not give up. Whether this was the result of discipline, leadership, shared identity, or some combination of all of these is a question that the accounts cannot fully answer. Whittlesey’s presence and his refusal to surrender were clearly important. McMurtry’s leadership of the 2nd Battalion’s portion of the perimeter was also documented as effective. The specific character of the men — draftees, New Yorkers, immigrants and their sons — may have contributed something that is harder to quantify: a commitment born of knowing that they had something to prove, that their fitness for the service and the citizenship it represented was being tested.

 

## The Pigeon Service’s Own History

 

The U.S. Army Signal Corps pigeon service had a history before and after the First World War that provides context for understanding Cher Ami’s place in it.

 

The American military had experimented with carrier pigeons in earlier conflicts, but the First World War represented the first systematic, large-scale deployment of pigeons as a military communications technology. The scale of the AEF pigeon service — with trained birds distributed to units across the front — was organized partly in collaboration with the British and French pigeon services, which had developed their systems over the previous three years.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.