Frank A. Blazich Jr., the curator of modern military history at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History, researched this question in detail. His July 2021 article in the Journal of Military History, titled “Notre Cher Ami: The Enduring Myth and Memory of a Humble Pigeon,” examined the Signal Corps records, the Army’s own documentation, and the institutional processes by which the legend was constructed and maintained. His conclusion was that there is “nothing conclusive” linking Cher Ami’s message to the cessation of the friendly-fire barrage or to the eventual relief of the Lost Battalion’s position.
This is a significant scholarly finding. It does not mean nothing happened — a wounded pigeon did fly twenty-five miles, and a message did arrive. But it does mean that the causal claim at the center of the most common version of the story — that Cher Ami’s message directly stopped the shelling and saved the men — is not supported by the contemporaneous record.
What stopped the shelling is not definitively established. The artillery may have been corrected through other means — other messages, observers, or the passage of time and the realization that coordinates were wrong. The relationship between whatever correction was made and Cher Ami’s arrival remains unclear in the primary sources.
## The Battalion’s Situation After October 4
The end of the friendly-fire barrage on October 4 did not end the Lost Battalion’s ordeal. German attacks continued. Food and water remained unavailable. Casualties mounted. The force that had entered the forest with roughly 540 to 554 men was shrinking.
