## McMurtry’s Later Years and the Survivors’ Perspective

 

George McMurtry’s long life after the Lost Battalion gave him a perspective on the story’s development that few others could share. He had been there. He had seen what happened. He had watched the story grow into something larger than what he remembered.

 

McMurtry’s organizing of reunions suggests that he was not primarily interested in public recognition for himself, but in maintaining the community of people who had shared the experience. The reunions were private and social events, not public performances. They allowed the survivors to maintain a relationship to their shared history that was more authentic than what public commemoration required.

 

His funding of the reunions from his personal fortune — a significant expression of commitment — suggests that he found genuine value in maintaining these connections. The men who had been in the pocket with him were the people who understood what had happened, and maintaining contact with them was maintaining contact with the most significant experience of his life.

 

By the time of his death in 1958, all the key figures of the Lost Battalion story were gone. Whittlesey had disappeared in 1921. Holderman had died. Many of the enlisted men who had been in the pocket were also dead. The story had become history — something that could be described and commemorated but not participated in by anyone who had been there. McMurtry was among the last direct links to the events, and his death ended the possibility of firsthand correction of the legend’s inaccuracies.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.