## Whittlesey, McMurtry, and Holderman

 

The three American officers most closely associated with the Lost Battalion’s ordeal received the Medal of Honor. Whittlesey, McMurtry, and Captain Nelson Holderman, who had led one of the companies, were each recognized for their leadership during the five days of encirclement.

 

For Whittlesey, the Medal of Honor brought a kind of celebrity that he found difficult to manage. He was a private man, a lawyer who had gone to war and found himself transformed into a public symbol. After the armistice, he returned to New York, resumed his law practice, and tried to resume the life he had led before 1917. The celebrity would not leave him alone.

 

He was promoted to lieutenant colonel. In 1921, he was given the honor — and the burden — of escorting the body of America’s Unknown Soldier from France to the United States and to burial at Arlington National Cemetery. The experience of the ceremony, and of leading the Red Cross Roll Call in New York, left him visibly affected. He had spent years unable to separate himself from the deaths of the men who had served under him in the Argonne.

 

On November 26, 1921, Whittlesey boarded the S.S. Toloa in New York, bound for Cuba. Sometime during the night, he disappeared. He had left nine letters in his cabin. His body was never recovered. The death was ruled a suicide, though no account has been confirmed of exactly what happened. He was thirty-six years old.

 

McMurtry’s fate was different. He returned to civilian life, made a substantial fortune in the stock market, funded reunions for the battalion’s survivors, and died at the age of eighty-two in 1958.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.