In what investigators and journalists later described as a kidnapping, O’Keefe seized Vincent Costa — Pino’s cousin and a crew member — and held him for ransom. The demand was for a portion of O’Keefe’s share of the Brink’s money, payable by the other crew members. Pino paid a small ransom to secure Costa’s release.
The kidnapping made the internal tensions within the crew explicit. O’Keefe had demonstrated that he was willing to use extreme measures against his former partners. From the perspective of the other crew members, particularly Pino and McGinnis, the question was no longer whether O’Keefe was a problem but what to do about it.
The answer they settled on was the most direct one available.
—
## Elmer “Trigger” Burke
The decision to have O’Keefe killed required someone from outside the Boston crew — someone who could operate without the web of local relationships and loyalties that made the crew members visible to each other and to investigators. Pino turned to a professional.
Elmer “Trigger” Burke was a New York hitman with a reputation for efficiency and an unfortunate tendency toward recklessness that would eventually cost him. He had a criminal record and connections in both the New York and Boston underworlds. He was engaged to find O’Keefe and eliminate him.
Burke traveled to Boston and located O’Keefe in a housing project in Dorchester. What followed was not quiet. Burke chased O’Keefe for approximately half an hour, firing dozens of rounds from a machine gun. By the time the chase ended, O’Keefe had been shot in the leg but was alive. Burke left the scene believing O’Keefe was dead or mortally wounded.
