He described what had happened afterward: the distribution of the money, the agreements about holding their shares, the financial arrangements he had made with Maffie, the events that had led to the kidnapping of Costa and the subsequent attempt on his life.
The information O’Keefe provided gave the FBI the evidence it needed to construct an indictment.
The statute of limitations was now eleven days away.
—
## The Arrests: January 12, 1956
On January 12, 1956 — five days before the six-year statute of limitations deadline — the FBI moved.
Henry Baker, Vincent Costa, Michael Geagan, Adolph Maffie, Joseph McGinnis, and Anthony Pino were arrested in Boston. The arrests were coordinated to prevent any of the targets from learning that others were being picked up and fleeing.
James Faherty and Thomas Richardson were not among those arrested that day. They had been alerted or had otherwise gone to ground. They would remain at large for more than four months.
On January 18, 1956 — one day after the six-year anniversary of the robbery — O’Keefe appeared before a court and entered a guilty plea. His cooperation with the FBI had been formalized, and his plea reflected the arrangement under which he would serve as the prosecution’s principal witness against the other crew members.
The statute of limitations had expired on January 17 for the state robbery charges — but the federal charges, rooted in different legal theory, had different limitation periods. The timing of the January 12 arrests, five days before the state deadline, was precise and deliberate. The years of investigation had been building toward a window that was now closing, and the FBI had worked to ensure it could make its move before that window shut.
