The defendants who entered prison in 1956 were not young men. Most had spent decades in the Boston criminal world. The life sentences effectively meant the end of their active lives as criminals, though the Massachusetts parole system provided a path to eventual release for those who served enough time under the right circumstances.

By 1971, all of the surviving convicted Brink’s robbers had been paroled — with one exception. Joseph McGinnis, who O’Keefe had named as the mastermind of the operation and who had taken particular care to establish an alibi on the night of the robbery, died in prison before he could be paroled. The specific circumstances of his death and its timing in relation to parole eligibility are not documented in available sources in detail, but the outcome is consistent across accounts: McGinnis, alone among the surviving convicted crew members, never left prison alive.

Jazz Maffie, whose prison term is sometimes described as approximately fourteen years in some sources — a figure that would be consistent with parole before 1971 — served a substantial portion of his sentence before release.

Sandy Richardson, in a comment reported in various retrospective accounts, was quoted as having said the robbery was worth it. The comment, whatever its precise context, has become one of the fragments of quoted retrospection attached to the case. It is attributed, as such statements must be, without certainty about the full circumstances in which it was made.

O’Keefe himself received a four-year sentence in exchange for his cooperation and guilty plea. He was released from custody in 1960. He later collaborated with journalist Bob Considine on a book, *The Men Who Robbed Brink’s*, published in 1961, which presented his account of the robbery and its aftermath from his perspective. The book is a significant primary source but also a retrospective account with the limitations that all such accounts carry — it is O’Keefe’s version of events, presented after the fact by a participant with his own narrative interests.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.